Friday, July 2, 2010

Recession Blues-End of Middle Class

Economic scientists have not arrived in any consensus on the causes of the major economic recession-The Great Depression that originated in the USA. The great depression started in 1929 with the collapse US stock market prices. It lasted almost ten years and it had effects on many countries across the globe. The Great Depression stands as a warning before us, how the world economy could decline suddenly.
In this 21st century when the world is undergoing a financial recession, the repercussions could be far reaching than the Great Depression..The full world stares at the USA, seeing the ups and downs of the USA .But the fact is that many countries are already under financial recession. Austria, China, Greece, Spain, GCC etc are already affected.
The USA with their strong will power, assets, corporation of the citizens, far sighted rulers and strong Govt have overcome the Great Depression. The same strategy would be their to help them in the present recession.
India with its strong centralized banking rules and financial strategies has withstood a recession from happening here. But the present scenario does not seem hopeful. Main points to ponder are:-
1) India always held a pro socialistic view of economics even when it claimed to be a mixed economy. The attitude of many rulers towards industries was hostile. The same attitude was held by the masses. Making money was always considered as a thing to be despised. Or was jealousy the name of this strategy? So the state always had a control over the financial routes and forces. This has helped the country to overcome any drastic upside downs in economy. When the pain was less gain was also less.
2)Gandhiji’s vision was that the soul of India lies in it Villages. The economic reforms of the UPA Govt to uplift the masses of the villages, eradicate poverty and ensure employment are worth mentioning. When it came to impose control over financial policies the Government saw the huge picture-the corporate, but really failed to see the place where the things were getting twisted. The producers of goods are under strict validation and control of financial matters. But there is practically no control over the middle men and the retailers. The Socialistic economic thought always failed to view the actual exploitation taking place by the middle men. A product with production cost of Rs 1,is available for the end user at a rate of Rs.65.The producer of the product is getting a profit of Rs 5.The rest is the day robbing by the middle men and the retailer.
3) Another major problem is the hike in petroleum prices. Every minor hike in petroleum prize is followed by a disproportionate hike in transportation charges. When the state Governments have a say in the hike of bus and other transport charges, majority of the goods prizes are hiked disproportionately. For Example if there is a hike of Rs 1 on 1 liter of Petrol there would be a hike of Rs 5 to 20 on every item. Other products like vegetables on which there are no MRP prizes are hiked according to the whims and fancies of the retailers. If the inflation moves in this phase, Two years down the line the prize of sugar would be Rs 500/Kg. The danger hidden in this economic devastation would be atrocious. The end result would be economic depression followed by law and order chaos.
4) When it comes to the State of Kerala no special mention is needed on the hostility towards industries. The above mentioned jealousy attitude towards the rich always prevailed here. Kerala with its socialistic influence has overcome many of the social inequalities that prevailed in other states of India. The living standards, socio economic, hygienic and educational standards of Kerala are really high. The co existence of different classes of society –Lower class, lower middle, middle, upper middle, high and upper high are worth mentioning.
5) The middle class people keep the mainstream culture of the society. It is quite clear that there is a cultural deterioration evident if we look at the upper class or lower class strata of the society. The lower class with its unpolished mannerism, attitude, behavior and culture are becoming much prominent in Kerala. This includes the once despised menial workers who are earning much more than a school teacher or middle level employees in a private or Govt establishment.
6)Once the state of Kerala was deprived of higher educational opportunities. Now the number of Engineering colleges has outnumbered the number of private bus stands in Kerala. If SSLC was the minimum qualification once, it would be Btech in the future. The situation has been so worse that fresh engineers, Post Graduate Teachers and fresh MBBS doctors are working for a salary of Rs 3500/month. This is when the housemaids are getting Rs 5,000/month and auto rickshaw drivers are earning Rs 15,000 to Rs 2,0000/ month. When these so called workers are well protected by labour unions and labour laws ,the low income ,educated persons are undergoing great trauma. The so called menial workers decide their working hours, style, and they have grown very much arrogant. They shirk their duties whenever possible and are marked by imperfection in work to the core. On the other side the educated class is working for peanuts that too under high stress and without any job security. The purchasing power of these people are much less than that of the menial class. The culture of these classes is now becoming the culture of the society or the mainstream culture of Kerala. The name of the Malayalam movies, the stories and themes are the best indicative of this culture change.
This clearly indicates that there would be drastic change in the status quo of the socioeconomic culture if the Govt fail to arrest the inequalities that cause the society to tilt upside down. Social upliftment never means the majority of the masses should suffer.

1 comment:

  1. Good observations, Robin.

    It is high time we removed the reservation system. But most of the people in the government enjoy benefits from reservation based on caste. Also, they are the biggest vote banks. We are in kind of a deadlock...

    The ONLY way out is hardwork - the general category should outshine in education and money making. I know its not possible inside Kerala for the reasons you have pointed out. I think thats why we see a lot of NRKs / NRIs. And their money is what is supporting the economy of Kerala.

    So, ultimately, I believe its not the end of middle class or their culture. Economically and education wise, the general class is leading yet, I think.

    Dev.

    ReplyDelete